Uncategorized

Heat Pump or Furnace Plus AC? Compare Annual Costs With Local Energy Prices

Quick answer: Neither option is always cheaper. Compare the cost of delivering the same amount of heat, then add cooling, backup heat, service charges and installation costs. In the illustrative calculation below, a heat pump needs a seasonal heating COP above approximately 3.69 to beat a 96%-AFUE gas furnace at electricity priced at $0.21/kWh and gas at $1.60/therm—before auxiliary electricity and fixed-charge differences. This is a calculation using stated assumptions, not a savings forecast. The method follows DOE efficiency definitions and EIA energy conversions. (energy.gov)

1. Compare complete replacement projects, not equipment prices

Start with two written proposals that provide equivalent heating and cooling coverage:

  • Heat-pump project: Outdoor unit, matched indoor equipment, controls and any required backup heating.
  • Furnace-plus-AC project: Furnace, outdoor AC unit, matched indoor coil and controls.

Ask each bidder to identify whether electrical work, duct repairs, permits, condensate disposal, equipment removal and commissioning are included, excluded or subject to inspection. For the furnace proposal, also ask about combustion-air and venting work. Treat these as bid-comparison questions, not assumptions that every home needs every item.

ENERGY STAR recommends written, itemized estimates comparing cost, efficiency and warranties, with model numbers and project details recorded in the proposal. Its installation guidance also calls for proper sizing, airflow verification, refrigerant-charge checks and duct evaluation. ENERGY STAR’s contractor guidance and quality-installation checklist provide useful starting points.

Keep three totals separate:

  1. Installed project price
  2. Estimated annual operating cost
  3. Longer-term ownership cost, including maintenance, repairs and financing assumptions

Do not select an option solely because its modeled energy bill is lower. DOE’s cost-effectiveness guidance compares lifetime energy savings with any upfront price premium; a smaller annual bill does not automatically justify a larger installation expense. (energy.gov)

2. Find the price of additional energy—not your average bill

For operating-cost comparisons, identify what an additional kWh or therm will cost under your actual rate schedule.

A utility bill may contain usage charges, delivery charges, riders, credits and a fixed customer charge. Dividing the entire bill by consumption mixes these together. Puget Sound Energy’s published summaries illustrate the distinction: electricity has tiered usage prices, while its gas summary separately lists per-therm charges, a monthly basic charge and a monthly credit. (pse.com)

Use this process:

  • Confirm the rate-schedule name on your bill.
  • Add applicable usage-based supply, delivery and adjustment charges.
  • Apply the appropriate tier or time period.
  • Track fixed charges and non-usage credits separately.
  • Include applicable taxes when estimating your actual bill.

Dated U.S. example inputs: PSE’s Washington electricity summary effective May 1, 2026, lists Schedule 7 totals of $0.187465/kWh for the first 600 monthly kWh and $0.206882/kWh above that threshold, before municipal tax where applicable. Its gas summary effective February 1, 2026, lists Schedule 23 usage charges totaling $1.60088/therm, separately from monthly charges and credits. (pse.com)

The example below rounds these to $0.21/kWh and $1.60/therm. They are historical inputs from different effective dates—not a claim about one current bill or today’s rates. Replace both with the rates applicable to your home.

3. Estimate annual heating demand before estimating savings

Both systems must be compared against the same heating requirement.

A useful starting point for a gas-heated home is its annual space-heating fuel consumption. Separate out water heating, cooking and other gas uses before converting consumption into estimated useful heat. This remains an approximation: the furnace’s actual seasonal efficiency and changes in weather or thermostat settings introduce uncertainty.

The basic relationship is:

Estimated useful heating output = heating therms × 100,000 × furnace efficiency

EIA defines one therm as 100,000 Btu. DOE defines AFUE as annual heating output divided by annual fuel input; AFUE does not include the furnace’s electrical consumption. Consequently, blower and other auxiliary electricity need a separate allowance. (eia.gov)

Ask the contractor for two distinct calculations:

  • Design heating load: The heating rate needed at the selected winter design condition, in Btu/hour.
  • Annual heating requirement: The estimated heat needed over a year, in Btu or another energy unit.

Do not confuse equipment capacity with annual consumption. A unit’s Btu/hour rating does not tell you how many hours it will operate.

For sizing, insist on an evaluation of the actual home rather than floor area alone. ENERGY STAR specifically advises against rule-of-thumb sizing and recommends checking the home’s characteristics, airflow and ducts. See ENERGY STAR’s installation guidance.

4. Check heat-pump performance at relevant temperatures

A heat pump’s coefficient of performance, or COP, is heat output divided by electrical input, expressed in the same energy units. A COP of 3 means three units of heat output per unit of electricity consumed. It is not a promise that the system maintains that performance throughout winter. (energy.gov)

Ask for manufacturer data for the proposed equipment combination, including:

  • Heating capacity and electrical input at relevant outdoor temperatures
  • Performance near your location’s winter design temperature
  • Minimum and maximum output
  • Defrost and backup-heating treatment
  • Indoor-unit and installation conditions underlying the data

For a concrete illustration, Mitsubishi Electric’s published Smart Multi data book lists the MXZ-SM36NAM-U1 with a ducted configuration at COP 3.70 at 47°F. The same specification table lists rated heating capacity of 42,000 Btu/hour at 47°F, maximum capacity of 36,000 Btu/hour at 17°F, and maximum capacity of 29,000 Btu/hour at 5°F. These are stated test points with different rated/maximum labels—not a seasonal forecast or an equipment recommendation. (mylinkdrive.com)

Capacity and efficiency answer different questions. Capacity determines whether the equipment can meet the load; efficiency helps determine its cost while doing so.

For annual estimates, request a local weather-based model rather than treating a single-temperature COP as the seasonal average. NREL’s residential field research separately tracked compressor heating, auxiliary heating and defrost—operating modes that a useful estimate should account for. (heatpumpdata.energy.gov)

5. Work through a transparent annual-cost example

This is an illustrative calculation, not a measured home or contractor quote. All amounts are USD.

Assume:

Input Assumption
Annual useful heating requirement 60 million Btu
Electricity $0.21/kWh
Natural gas $1.60/therm
Replacement furnace AFUE 96%
Heat-pump seasonal COP 3.0
Resistance backup None in this first calculation
Distribution losses Assumed equivalent

The heat demand, efficiencies and cooling consumption below are chosen assumptions. The rounded energy prices come from the dated PSE snapshots described above.

Gas-furnace heating

Fuel consumption:

60,000,000 ÷ (100,000 × 0.96) = 625 therms

Heating fuel cost:

625 × $1.60 = $1,000/year

Add furnace electricity separately because AFUE excludes it. (energy.gov)

Heat-pump heating

Using EIA’s conversion of 3,412 Btu per kWh:

60,000,000 ÷ (3,412 × 3.0) ≈ 5,862 kWh

Heating electricity cost:

5,862 × $0.21 ≈ $1,231/year (eia.gov)

Under these assumptions, heat-pump heating costs approximately $231 more annually, before the omitted items.

Add cooling to both paths

Suppose, strictly for illustration, each proposed system uses 1,500 kWh annually for cooling:

1,500 × $0.21 = $315/year

Replacement path Modeled heating and cooling energy subtotal
Furnace plus AC $1,315
Heat pump $1,546

These are not complete annual ownership costs. They exclude maintenance, repairs, fixed-charge differences, taxes and furnace auxiliary electricity. Cooling is deliberately held equal to isolate the heating comparison; replace it with separate estimates for the actual proposals.

Find the heating break-even COP

With electricity price E in dollars/kWh, gas price G in dollars/therm and furnace efficiency η as a decimal:

Break-even COP ≈ 29.31 × E × η ÷ G

For this example:

29.31 × 0.21 × 0.96 ÷ 1.60 ≈ 3.69

Above that seasonal COP, the heat pump has the lower modeled heating-energy cost; below it, the furnace does. The formula excludes backup heat and fixed-charge differences.

6. Stress-test backup heat, prices and winter performance

Change one assumption at a time before trusting the result.

For the same assumed 60-million-Btu heating requirement:

Changed assumption Heat-pump heating cost Furnace fuel cost
Baseline: COP 3.0 $1,231 $1,000
Seasonal COP falls to 2.0 $1,846 $1,000
Seasonal COP rises to 4.0 $923 $1,000
Electricity falls to $0.15/kWh $879 $1,000
Gas rises to $2.20/therm $1,231 $1,375
Resistance supplies 10% of annual heat; compressor supplies 90% at COP 3.0 $1,477 $1,000

These are calculated scenarios, not predicted rates or field results.

In the final row, 10% means a share of delivered heat—not operating hours. The remaining 90% uses the heat pump at COP 3.0. Do not add that backup allowance if the seasonal efficiency estimate already includes it.

A dual-fuel system needs a different calculation: divide annual heat between the heat pump and furnace, then price each share. ENERGY STAR describes dual fuel as combining a heat pump with a gas or oil furnace, allowing either heating source to be used. (energystar.gov)

Ask the contractor to distinguish the capacity balance point, where heat-pump output meets the house load, from the economic changeover point, where one heat source becomes cheaper under the assumed prices. Request proposed control settings and the calculations behind them; do not change safety-related settings yourself.

7. Use these checks before choosing a proposal

Before accepting a savings estimate, check for these common errors:

  • Old equipment versus only one new option: Compare the replacement heat pump against the replacement furnace and AC you would otherwise buy.
  • Whole gas bill treated as heating: Separate other appliances’ consumption.
  • Fixed charges counted as avoided automatically: Model gas-account closure separately from continued gas service.
  • A 47°F COP used for the whole winter: Request a local seasonal estimate.
  • Backup counted twice—or omitted: Confirm what the efficiency model includes.
  • Different installation scopes: Align ductwork, electrical work, controls and commissioning.

PSE’s gas summary illustrates why account-level modeling matters: its monthly basic charge and carbon-reduction credit are separate from per-therm charges. Eliminating gas service therefore requires checking both charges and credits, not simply multiplying the basic charge by twelve. (pse.com)

Finally, request a one-page comparison showing model numbers, installed scope, annual heating and cooling energy, backup assumptions, applicable tariffs and excluded costs. ENERGY STAR recommends itemized proposals and documented installation checks. Use its hiring checklist to organize that conversation.

Choose using a range, not a single savings number. If small changes in COP, fuel prices or backup use reverse the result, operating cost alone is not a strong basis for paying a large upfront premium.